Why all diets depend on livestock farming

You are intrigued about our poster in Signature Dish project with The Parliament and European Food Forum; as vegan, vegetarian or flexitarian yourself, how do you have a connection to a European livestock farmer ? As paradoxical as it can sound, let’s forget the campaigning around diets and food choices, and take a closer look!

The debate around livestock is often framed as a simple choice between “plant-based vs. animal-based diets”. But if we look at the debate not from the plate, but from the farm, European agriculture is more complex than this binary suggests. Even diets containing little or no animal products remain connected to livestock farming because animals play an important role in how agricultural systems use land, recycle nutrients and generate value from biomass.

Livestock helps make use of land that cannot grow food for humans

A simple but often forgotten fact: a significant share of agricultural land consists of grassland and pasture, or land that is unsuitable for efficient crop production because of climate, soil, slope or water constraints. Removing livestock won’t turn this land into fields producing cereals, pulses or vegetables.

In many cases, we are actually observing the opposite phenomenon, with certain areas becoming increasingly overgrown or closed off, in mountain regions where pastoral farming is declining, as well as an increase in wildfires in these same areas. Grazing livestock therefore provides a way of producing food from land that has few, if any, alternatives for direct human food production.

Animals are also part of nutrient recycling

Modern crop production requires nutrients, particularly nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium. Livestock plays an important role in closing this “nutrient cycle”: manure returns organic matter and nutrients to agricultural soils, helping maintain soil fertility and reducing reliance on external fertilisers. This is particularly important in mixed farming systems, where crops provide feed for animals and animals provide manure for crops.

Without livestock, these nutrient flows still need to be managed and replaced through other means, such as mineral fertilisers, compost or digestate. In the current geopolitical context, this synergy has also taken on greater importance, particularly during the Strait of Hormuz crisis, which highlighted the EU’s strategic vulnerability in this area and prompted the European Commission to propose a fertiliser action plan aimed at increasing the use of livestock-derived fertilisers across agricultural production systems.

Plant food production also produces large amounts of non-edible biomass

Another fact that is largely absent from the public debate on the topic: crop farming does not produce only the part of a plant that humans eat! A crop produces an entire plant. Straw, bran, beet pulp, oilseed meals, residues from food processing and biomass from intercrops are examples of materials that humans generally cannot eat.

In general, research estimates that one kilogram of plant-based food for human consumption is associated with at least 3–5 kilograms of non-edible plant biomass. This is an inevitable consequence of producing plant food. One key question farmers have tried to answer for centuries has therefore been: how this biomass can best be valorised?

It can remain on the field, be composted, be used in biogas production, or be used as animal feed. Livestock has long been considered one of the most valuable pathways because animals can convert non-edible biomass into high-quality meat and dairy products while returning a significant proportion of plant nutrients to agriculture through manure.

For example, oilseed processing produces vegetable oil for human consumption but also oilseed meals that are valuable sources of animal feed. Sugar production generates beet pulp, while cereal production generates straw and bran. These products can be integrated into valuable livestock feeding systems rather than being treated as waste.

If we imagine a purely “vegan-oriented agricultural system” in which livestock farming is drastically reduced, it would no longer be able to recycle and valorise the full amount of non-edible biomass generated alongside plant food production through livestock. Some residues could remain on fields, be composted or enter other bioenergy and industrial pathways, but these alternatives would not necessarily provide the same combination of biomass valorisation, food production and nutrient recycling.

Without livestock, a substantial share of this material would therefore have to be managed through alternative pathways, creating additional management, economic and environmental challenges rather than being transformed into additional human-edible products.

A plant-based diet changes the livestock system but does not necessarily eliminate the synergies

Eating less animal food reduces demand for livestock production, but the relationship between plant-based diets and livestock is more complex than the slogan “plant versus animal” suggests.

In a future where Europeans consume less meat and dairy, well-integrated livestock farming will always remain an important part of the future of the EU agricultural system. Livestock can complement crop, fruit and vegetable production by making use of land that cannot efficiently produce food for humans, valorising non-edible biomass and recycling nutrients back into the soil.

Ultimately, the good health and resilience of livestock farming can contribute to the resilience and productivity of crop, fruit and vegetable production, as well as to the production of a wide range of bio-based and natural products.